When in Star mode, create a player in the Italian league (the easiest). When you get to the attributes, divide the 20 points between Dribble Accuracy and Precision. When in the part of the special abilities, put the star in medium distance kicking. During the first match, press R2 repeatedly to get the ball. Do a short dribble and kick from not too far, not too close from the goal. If done correctly, it should be an easy goal. Repeat this trick at the same match to increase the chance of being contracted by a good or a medium team.
Star mode: Positions
Begin Star mode until the part with the positions. If you want to be a front man, put the three top positions. For a balanced player, put the three in the middle. For a defense player put the three on the lower edge.