| Trophy | How to unlock | Type
|
|---|
| Big Grab | Rob a home run -- any mode | Bronze
|
| Derby Champ | Win the HR Derby against CPU - Official settings only | Bronze
|
| Feel The Squeeze | Win a game on a Suicide Squeeze (runner leaves 3rd before contact on a bunt) vs CPU or Ranked Match | Bronze
|
| Fool Me Once | Tag a runner out in rundown using pump fake (Online Ranked Match only) | Bronze
|
| Hardware Hunter | Win the World Series (Franchise Mode only - no simmed games during season) | Silver
|
| Head to Head | Win an Online Ranked Match | Bronze
|
| Long Haul | Complete full season in Franchise Mode | Bronze
|
| Old-Time Hurler | Win a Complete Game with a single Legend Pitcher (9-inning game) | Bronze
|
| Old-Time Tater | Hit a grand slam with a Legend player | Bronze
|
| Patience Prevails | Score an RBI on a walk vs CPU or Ranked Match | Bronze
|
| Pitcher's Best Friend | Turn double play on a comebacker to pitcher vs CPU or Ranked Match | Bronze
|
| R.B.I. Royalty | Hit 1000 RBIs (any mode) | Silver
|
| Ready To Go | Complete all gameplay tutorials | Bronze
|
| Sac Attack | Score a run after tagging up on fly ball vs CPU or Ranked Match | Bronze
|
| Taters Served All Day | Hit back to back to back home runs in Derby | Bronze
|
| Top Dog Home Runs | Beat the 2017 HR leader: 60 Home Runs in a season with a single player | Bronze
|
| Top Dog Stolen Bases | Beat the 2017 Stolen Base leader: 61 Stolen Bases in a season with a single player | Bronze
|
| Top Dog Wins | Beat the 2017 Wins leader: 19 Wins in a season with a single pitcher | Bronze
|
| Wheel and Deal | Complete Trade with CPU in Franchise Mode | Bronze
|